|
Brainy Winners: 2004 Business Plan Competition
Reprinted From The Get It Started Newsletter (www.wep.wharton.upenn.edu)
Health science trumped the Internet—and everything else—at the 2004
Venture Fair, the culmination of the
2003-2004 Wharton Business Plan
Competition. The grand prize went to
InfraScan, which has created a device
to detect brain bleeding; the second
prize went to CelfCure, which would
treat neurological ailments with transplanted stem cells; and third place
went to BioSpectrum, which aims
to improve the way pharmaceutical
companies screen for potential drugs.
Distributed Resource Imagery, a computer animation company, won the
Frederick H. Gloeckner Award as the
best Wharton undergraduate team.
As the winners, InfraScan's team
members—two Wharton MBA students and an Israeli physicist—collected $20,000, entry into Wharton's
Venture Initiation Program and a chance
to present their business plan at the
Global Start-up @Singapore competition (Co-organized by INSEAD and
the National University of Singapore
Entrepreneurship Center). CelfCure
received $10,000, and BioSpectrum,
$5,000. All three teams also will receive $10,000 worth of combined legal
and accounting services.
"For the purpose of raising funds,
this is extraordinary PR," said
InfraScan founder Baruch Ben Dor, an
Israel-trained physicist who moved to
Philadelphia in hopes of launching an
entrepreneurial venture. "My problem
was getting through the first five seconds with a venture capitalist. Winning
the Business Plan Competition gives me
the first five minutes of his attention."
"Nearly 200 student teams participated in this year's competition,"
said Emily Cieri, managing director of
Wharton Entrepreneurial Programs,
which co-manages the event with a
student team. "We touched over 700
students across campus, whether
they competed or just attended our
workshops. We had submissions from
10 of the 12 professional schools
across campus." Any team that includes a University of Pennsylvania
student can participate.
InfraScan's entry was built on its
HematoScope. The handheld device
would let emergency room physicians
and emergency medical technicians
do quick scans of people with head
trauma to determine the extent of their
injuries. About the size of a personal
digital assistant, it could help hospitals, especially those in the developing
world, more efficiently use scarce CT
scanners and MRIs. A patient would be
sent for a CT or MRI scan only if the
HematoScope detected brain bleeding.
Ben Dor met his teammates—Sandeep Naik, WG'04, and Samonnoi
Banerjee, WG'05—through a posting
he placed on a Wharton web site. He
sought help with his business plan and
investor presentation. Naik responded,
suggested they enter the competition,
and enlisted Banerjee.
Naik had worked at Medtronic, a
Minnesota medical-device maker before coming to Wharton. Thanks to his
background, he quickly sensed the
HematoScope's potential.
"I asked Baruch tons of questions.
And the more I questioned him, the
more I realized that the technology is
very simple and low cost. It's mobile,
too. And I found out there's a huge unmet need."
Naik, with Banerjee's assistance,
wrote the business plan and delivered
the team's 10-minute presentation at
the Venture Fair. After that, the competition's panel of eight judges—investors, entrepreneurs and a journalist—peppered him and Ben Dor with
questions for 10 more minutes.
"This is not just a concept," Naik
said during his talk. "We have a working prototype and have conducted
human clinical trials on 305 patients."
He argued that the HematoScope could
help reduce health care costs by eliminating unnecessary
scans on expensive-to-operate CT and MRI machines.
InfraScan's scanner grew out of a
patent on research by Britton Chance,
an emeritus professor of biophysics,
biochemistry and radiology at Penn.
Chance is something of a legend within
his field and at the University. Though
91 years old, he still does research,
traveling to his on-campus lab by bicycle.
In 1952, he won an Olympic gold
medal in sailing as part of a three-man
team in the 5.5 meter class.
Ben Dor, a former Israeli Air Force
captain, was familiar with Chance's
research and sought him out. Chance
decided to hire Ben Dor as chief executive of a dormant company he'd created
called NIM, which stands for noninvasive medicine.
Chance had started NIM to
commercialize the near-infrared technology that undergirds the HematoScope.
InfraScan spun out of NIM.
The device "projects light of the
proper wavelength into the brain to detect whether there's bleeding," Chance
explains. "Shed blood absorbs a lot of
light, so spilled blood gives a bigger
signal than non spilled blood."
Second-place CelfCure aims to treat
neurological ailments, too. It wants
to harness what's called manipulated
autologus stem cell therapy, or MAST.
In MAST, physicians take cells from a
patient's body, culture them in a lab,
load them with drugs, then put them
back in the patient. The technology,
which has shown promise in research
labs, can be used to treat problems
such as head and spinal-cord injuries
and stroke. So far, it isn't available for
practicing doctors.
The problem, says team member
Ajay Bakshi, a neurosurgeon and researcher, is that "biotech companies
don't have access to patients, and hospitals don't know how to grow cells."
CelfCure would act as a bridge, providing the cultured cells and techniques
for transplantation. "Our business
proposition rests on developing MAST
technologies for various diseases and
making them available for medical use
by establishing a centralized laboratory," the team explains in the written
summary of its plan.
Third-place BioSpectrum also offers
a technology that it believes could help
existing health care companies—in its
case, drug companies—operate more
effectively. It has devised a faster means of
screening proteins that
have a role in diseases.
As with conventional
screens, its technology
would test the proteins'
responses to large libraries of chemical
compounds.
"Understanding proteins enables
drug researchers to target more effectively
the root causes of disease earlier
in the drug-development process, thus
saving time and money in a process
that currently requires on average 15
years and $800 million," the team
explained in a summary of its plan.
BioSpectrum's technology allows it to
miniaturize the chemical reactions required
to run screens. That lets it run
more screens on the standard-sized
plates that drug companies use for the
tests and reduce waste. Rather than
licensing its technology, BioSpectrum
would perform screens for drug companies
and contract-research companies.
Rounding out the Great Eight, as the
finalists are known, were Greenhands,
a retailer of environmentally friendly fuels;
IL Aerospace Technologies, a space
tourism company; Integrated Biometric
Solutions, a developer of biometric entry
systems for hotels; and Solestia, a
provider of solar-system financing.
An eight-person panel judged the
finals of this year's competition. The
panel included representatives of St.
Paul Venture Capital, Canaan Partners,
JK & B Capital, Johnson & Johnson,
Sienna Ventures, Microsoft and
"This is not just a concept," Naik
said. "We have a working prototype
and have conducted human clinical
trials on 305 patients." Business 2.0 magazine. Entrepreneur John Osher, a former
Wharton Entrepreneur-in-Residence, also served as a judge.
More than 300 volunteers served as judges for earlier stages
of the competition and as mentors for the participants.
WEP's Cieri said the hefty number of participants, from
students to alumni and friends of Wharton, distinguished
this year's competitions from prior ones. "We had a 45 percent
increase in the number of judges," she pointed out.
This year's competition also scored several firsts.
For the first time, a team from Wharton West—IL
Aerospace Technologies—and two undergraduate teams
—Distributed Resource Imagery and Integrated Biometric
Solutions—made it to the finals.
To find out more, visit Get It Started at www.wep.wharton.edu.
|